top of page

10 September 2025

Submission

Digital Competition Regime

Christophe Carugati

Digital Competition’s Submission to the Commission Public Consultation on the Digital Markets Act Review

Reviewing the Digital Markets Act’s implementation as of July 2025, the submission highlights designation imbalances, warns against premature scope expansion, and calls for clearer compliance guidance and deeper cooperation with national authorities.

Executive Summary

 

Adopted in 2022, the Digital Markets Act (DMA) imposes obligations on large online platforms to ensure contestable and fair digital markets. The Commission is consulting stakeholders ahead of its first review report, due by 26 May 2026. This submission provides a factual overview, critical analysis, and policy recommendations to the Commission across the designation process, compliance phase, and cooperation frameworks as of July 2025.

 

The designation process has operated as intended. However, concerns have been raised about an imbalance between designated U.S. platforms and similarly sized European and Chinese firms, recommending the latter to be designated to level the playing field. While calls to expand the DMA to cover cloud and GenAI services are growing, the Commission should first monitor these dynamic and nascent markets before extending the scope.

 

Compliance is still in its early stages of development. While merger reporting functions well, no cases have been referred under the European Merger Regulation (EUMR), and the Commission should assess the reasons before revising its merger policy. Compliance and consumer profiling reports offer limited value to stakeholders and should be made more accessible to them. The Commission should also structure the informal dialogue process, prioritise cooperative resolution, clarify its use of specification decisions over non-compliance investigations, issue guidance on key obligations, and monitor GenAI developments to ensure the DMA remains fit for purpose before changing obligations.

 

Existing cooperation mechanisms and forums have supported consistent enforcement, but can be strengthened. The Commission should deepen its collaboration with national competent authorities, particularly national competition authorities (NCAs), through practical frameworks, increased transparency, and enhanced stakeholder engagement dynamic and nascent markets.

Keywords

Digital competition regimes

Digital Markets Act

About the paper

This submission is part of our Digital Competition Regime Hub. The Hub provides research on the design, implementation, and enforcement of digital competition regimes worldwide. We address your challenges through tailored research projects, consultations, regulatory intelligence, training sessions, conferences, and think tank membership. Contact us for membership, service, or press inquiries. This submission was conducted independently and did not receive any funding. It reflects solely the views of its author and not of its clients, which include Amazon. We extend our gratitude to stakeholders who provided valuable insights.

About the author

Christophe Carugati

Dr. Christophe Carugati is the founder of Digital Competition. He is a renowned and passionate expert on digital and competition issues with a strong reputation for doing impartial, high-quality research. After his PhD in law and economics on Big Data and Competition Law, he is an ex-affiliate fellow at the economic think-tank Bruegel and an ex-lecturer in competition law and economics at Lille University.

Related content

© 2025 Digital Competition by Dr. Christophe Carugati

Subscribe to our newsletter

Thanks for subscribing!

bottom of page