Editorial
The monthly newsletter is becoming the Voice of Digital Competition: a space for my work and a forum for different perspectives, offering concise analyses of market and regulatory developments.
But the voice is not only mine. I will soon open the newsletter to invited guest experts, featured in a “Guest Voice Expert” section—including academics, lawyers, economists, competition officials, and in-house professionals—to share their perspectives and contribute to the debate through short, insightful comments.
In this first edition, the Commission is adopting a new enforcement approach to digital markets. Rather than reacting to competition concerns, it is proactively intervening in cloud and AI markets under the Digital Markets Act, the EU’s digital competition regulation, to ensure they remain competitive from the outset. And rather than relying solely on lengthy formal investigations, the Commission is increasingly engaging with gatekeepers to address competition concerns through informal regulatory dialogue.
At the same time, market developments in the AI sector—from AI agents to NVIDIA’s acquisition of Hugging Face—continue to reshape digital markets.
Enjoy!
To contribute, write to me at: Christophe.carugati@digital-competition.com
My Work
Analysis: Gatekeeper Acquisitions Under the DMA: Market Trends and Implications for Merger Policy
Gatekeeper acquisitions increasingly target Artificial Intelligence (AI). Existing merger control tools are sufficient to review these transactions. However, the Commission should remove the proposed unjustified exception for gatekeepers from its draft merger guidelines.
Opinion: The CMA Should Get App Store Rules Right
The UK could become the first country to set principles for app store steering fees. It should explain more convincingly why digital markets deserve utility-style pricing.
The AI agents and Competition Training delves into the competition implications of AI agents, both upstream and downstream, to help tech firms, law firms, and economic consulting firms build the expertise needed to navigate these emerging challenges.
Conference: AI in Practice: Moving towards an Agentic Future
I will share insights into the competitive functioning of AI agents with Elizabeth Sinclair (Clifford Chance) and Jonny Ford (Linklaters) at the ICC conference in London on 16 September.
Conference: Digital Markets, AI, and the Future of Competition Law
I will present a paper on AI agents co-authored with Professor Bruno Deffains at Roma Tre Law School in Rome on 25 September.
The Crossroads
The Commission shapes new digital markets
The Commission is increasingly shaping new digital markets, particularly cloud and Artificial Intelligence (AI), under the Digital Markets Act (DMA).
Over the summer, the Commission issued guidance to Google requiring Android to interoperate with AI services and Google Search to share search data with competing search engines, including AI services with search functionalities such as ChatGPT. It also issued a non-compliance decision against Google over promoting its own services on Google Search, with explicit references to its AI services (AI Mode and AI Overviews). Finally, the Commission issued preliminary findings that Amazon Web Services (AWS) and Microsoft Azure (Azure) should be designated as cloud computing service providers, which is an infrastructure layer that enables the development and deployment of AI services at scale.
These actions point to two important shifts in enforcement. First, the Commission is moving from reactive to proactive enforcement: rather than waiting for competitive harm to materialise, it seeks to remove potential obstacles to competition from the outset. Second, it is increasingly intervening not only where markets are already uncompetitive, but also where competitive dynamics are still developing.
The Commission is therefore doing more than correcting market failures: it is helping shape the markets of the future. This approach may prevent competitive problems from arising, but it also creates a fundamental risk: regulatory intervention can shape market outcomes in ways that ultimately lead markets to perform less well than they otherwise would.
The Commission solves digital cases informally
The Commission is increasingly resolving DMA cases through regulatory dialogue with gatekeepers, allowing companies to address concerns raised during non-compliance investigations without a formal infringement decision.
Over the summer, Apple changed the terms and conditions of its App Store, while Google changed its site reputation policy. Both changes followed regulatory dialogue with the Commission, potentially closing the investigations.
This approach allows the Commission to resolve cases more quickly and efficiently. But it also raises questions about transparency and the role of third parties in the regulatory process.
The Commission's approach contrasts sharply with the UK’s. Over the summer, the Competition and Markets Authority actively engaged with stakeholders through invitations to comment before designing regulatory interventions concerning Google Search and Apple's steering terms. The Commission should take note to improve its approach.
AI agents are competitive
From search engines to e-commerce, digital markets are becoming increasingly agentic, with AI agents acting on users' behalf.
The French Competition Authority recently published an opinion finding that AI agents remain competitive for now, while identifying potential competition risks, including algorithmic collusion. It concludes with several recommendations to preserve competition as the market develops.
The direction of travel is clear, but fundamental questions remain. How will AI agents reshape digital markets, particularly intermediation services? Could AI agents autonomously implement anti-competitive strategies? If so, how can competition authorities intervene effectively?
NVIDIA acquires Hugging Face
NVIDIA, the leading AI chipmaker, is acquiring Hugging Face, one of the largest open-source repositories of AI models and data, for $12 billion. The deal, one of the largest AI acquisitions to date, raises interesting questions about competitiveness and competition.
On competitiveness, French entrepreneurs founded Hugging Face. I wonder whether the French government would intervene today on “sovereignty” grounds if the company were still French. In my view, however, sovereignty would be a poor justification for intervention: the merger aims to strengthen Hugging Face and, in turn, its global competitiveness.
On competition, the merger gives NVIDIA a distribution channel for its open models, data and chips, while Hugging Face will remain an open platform where developers can choose what to build and deploy using the models, data and chips of their choice.
So, at first sight, there is no obvious alarm bell. Yet questions remain: could NVIDIA self-preference its models and data on Hugging Face? Could it give developers building or deploying through the platform preferential access to its chips?